Manufacturing Mutual Funds: Which Is the Better SIP Or Lumsump?

Home - Finance - Manufacturing Mutual Funds: Which Is the Better SIP Or Lumsump?


Manufacturing mutual funds, which primarily invest in companies within the manufacturing sector, offer investors an opportunity to benefit from the growth potential of industries such as automotive, electronics, pharmaceuticals, and consumer goods. When it comes to investing in these funds, investors often face the dilemma of choosing between Systematic Investment Plans (SIPs) and lumpsum investments.

Both methods have advantages and drawbacks, depending on various factors including market conditions, investor risk tolerance, and financial goals.

This article delves into the comparison between SIP and lumpsum investments in manufacturing mutual funds to help you make an informed decision.

Understanding Systematic Investment Plan and Lumpsum Investments

Systematic Investment Plan (SIP)

A SIP allows investors to invest a fixed amount of money at regular intervals, typically monthly. This method teaches a disciplined saving habit and leverages the concept of rupee cost averaging, which helps mitigate the impact of market volatility.

Lumpsum Investment

A lumpsum investment involves investing a substantial amount of money in one go. This method requires precise market timing and is generally more suited to investors who have a significant amount of idle funds and a high risk tolerance.

The advantages of a Systematic Investment Plan are as follows:

Rupee Cost Averaging: SIP helps in averaging out the cost of purchase by investing a fixed amount regularly, irrespective of the market conditions. This means buying more units when prices are low and fewer units when prices are high.

Disciplined Investing: SIP encourages regular investment habits, making it easier for investors to build a corpus over time without worrying about market timing.

Reduced Impact of Volatility: Since investments are spread over a period, the impact of market volatility is minimized.

Flexibility: Investors can start with a small amount and gradually increase their SIP contributions as their financial situation improves.

The following are some disadvantages:

Long-term Commitment: SIPs require a long-term commitment to realize significant benefits, which might not suit investors with short-term financial goals.

Missed Opportunities: During strong bull markets, SIP might result in lower returns compared to lumpsum investments due to the averaging effect.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Lumpsum

Potential for Higher Returns: If invested during market lows, lumpsum investments can yield higher returns compared to SIPs by taking full advantage of market recoveries.

Simplicity: Lumpsum investment is straightforward, with no need for regular monitoring and monthly contributions.

Immediate Exposure: Investors gain immediate and full exposure to market movements, which can be beneficial in rising markets.

The following are some disadvantages:

Market Timing Risk: Lumpsum investments carry a significant risk if the market drops shortly after investing, potentially leading to substantial short-term losses.

Volatility Impact: The full exposure to market volatility can be challenging to manage for risk-averse investors.

High Entry Barrier: A significant amount of idle funds is required to make a lumpsum investment, which might not be feasible for all investors.

Which is Better for Manufacturing Mutual Funds?

In terms of market conditions, let us see which is better:

Volatile or Bearish Markets: SIPs are generally better suited for volatile or bearish market conditions, as they spread the investment over time and mitigate the risk of investing a large amount at a market peak.

Bullish Markets: Lumpsum investments can be more beneficial during bullish market phases, allowing investors to capitalize on rising market trends.

In terms of Investor Profile, let’s s check which one is better:

Risk Tolerance: Risk-averse investors might prefer SIPs for their ability to reduce the impact of market volatility. Conversely, risk-tolerant investors might opt for lumpsum investments to maximize returns during market upswings.

Investment Horizon: For investors with a long-term horizon, SIPs offer a disciplined approach to building wealth gradually. However, those with substantial funds and a higher risk appetite might find lumpsum investments more appealing for their potential to deliver higher returns in favourable market conditions.

Financial Goals: SIPs are ideal for investors with long-term goals like retirement planning or children’s education. Lumpsum investments are better suited for those aiming for short to medium-term financial goals, provided they are comfortable with market risks.

5 Best Manufacturing Funds for Investment in 2024

  1. ICICI Prudential Manufacturing Fund

The ICICI Prudential Manufacturing Fund focuses on investing in companies that are part of the manufacturing sector. The fund aims to capitalize on the growth potential within this sector, driven by industrial development and policy support for manufacturing activities in India.

Here are some key features:

Sector Focus: Concentrates on manufacturing industries such as automotive, chemicals, industrial machinery, and capital goods.

Investment Approach: Combines bottom-up stock picking with a top-down sectoral analysis to identify high-potential companies.

Suitability: Suitable for investors looking for sector-specific growth opportunities and willing to accept higher risk due to sector concentration.

  1. Quant Manufacturing Fund

The Quant Manufacturing Fund seeks to generate long-term capital appreciation by primarily investing in companies within the manufacturing and related sectors. The fund leverages quantitative models to identify investment opportunities.

Let us learn the key features:

Quantitative Approach: Utilizes data-driven models and algorithms to select stocks with favourable growth prospects and valuation metrics.

Sector Focus: Targets diverse manufacturing sub-sectors including heavy industries, consumer durables, and industrial goods.

Suitability: Ideal for investors who prefer a systematic, quantitative investment approach and are interested in the manufacturing sector.

  1. Nippon India Manufacturing Fund

The Nippon India Manufacturing Fund aims to provide long-term capital growth by investing predominantly in equity and equity-related instruments of manufacturing companies. The fund leverages Nippon India’s robust research capabilities to identify promising investment opportunities.

The following are some vital key Features:

Research-Driven: Focuses on in-depth fundamental research to select high-quality manufacturing companies.

Diverse Exposure: Invests across a wide range of manufacturing industries, offering broad exposure within the sector.

Suitability: Suitable for investors seeking diversified exposure to the manufacturing sector with a research-backed investment strategy.

  1. HDFC Manufacturing Fund

Overview: HDFC Manufacturing Fund aims to generate long-term capital appreciation by investing in a diversified portfolio of manufacturing companies. The fund benefits from HDFC’s extensive market research and industry analysis.

Let’s check the key features:

Diverse Portfolio: Includes companies from various manufacturing sub-sectors such as engineering, capital goods, and consumer durables.

Experienced Management: Managed by experienced fund managers with a strong track record in sectoral funds.

Suitability: Ideal for investors looking for a well-researched, diversified manufacturing sector fund with a long-term investment horizon.

  1. Axis Manufacturing Fund

Axis Manufacturing Fund focuses on capitalizing on the growth potential of the manufacturing sector by investing in high-quality manufacturing companies. The fund aims to deliver long-term capital appreciation through a selective investment approach.

Here are some key features:

Quality Focus: Emphasizes investing in companies with strong management, competitive advantages, and robust financials.

Selective Strategy: Utilizes a bottom-up approach to pick stocks, ensuring a focus on quality and sustainable growth.

Suitability: Suitable for investors seeking quality exposure to the manufacturing sector with a focus on long-term growth and stability.


Choosing between SIP and lumpsum investments in manufacturing mutual funds depends on various factors such as market conditions, investor risk tolerance, investment horizon, and financial goals. SIPs offer a disciplined and risk-averse approach, suitable for volatile markets and long-term wealth creation. On the other hand, lumpsum investments can provide higher returns in bullish markets for investors who can tolerate market risks and have significant idle funds.

Ultimately, a blended strategy incorporating both SIP and lumpsum investments might be the most effective way to leverage the benefits of both approaches while mitigating their respective drawbacks. By understanding your financial situation and market dynamics, you can make a well-informed decision that aligns with your investment goals.

Table of Contents

Written by pawansharma